Thrifting Tips for an Overwhelmed First Timer

Over the weekend, I convinced an “I hate shopping” person to try thrifting for the first time. Which got me to thinking how absolutely overwhelming it can be even just walking into the store to try and find something.

In this case, we were targeting the kid’s clothes, which made it a bit easier to be ‘strategic’ about what we were looking for. If you’ve been wanting to try thrifting and don’t know where to start, here are a few of my tips for a thrifting first timer:

Do Your Homework

Write down a list of what you want/need before you come. If you know you need winter items in a size 4T, write down on a piece of paper or in your phone EXACTLY what you’re looking for: winter coat, long sleeve shirts, sweatshirts, sweatpants, mittens, etc. Check your drawers to see what you already have too, so that you don’t buy a duplicate you don’t actually need.

Go Straight to your Targeted Section

Go to the section on your list FIRST. This helps with thrift fatigue. It’s super easy to get distracted by all the cool stuff and suddenly you’re in the electronics department or picking out a new set of dishes and you’re too exhausted to even deal with the kid’s section. Stick to the plan – at least when you walk in the door.

Accumulate, and Then Purge

Go through the row and grab everything that meets your criteria and throw it in your cart. Then, once you’ve gone through all the options, pull your cart over out of the way and hang your items up to review them. Put all the sweatpants together, the long sleeve tops, etc. Then, go through each group one by one to make your selections. Pick your favorites, check for wear/stains/holes and don’t forget to compare prices. Sometimes a very similar item can have a wildly different price, so make an educated decision.

Do a Second Round but Expand Sizing

Go through the racks again, now that you know where you’re still lacking items. And this time, expand your search to the next size up. Many times things are donated due to shrinkage or sizing issues… so be sure to check other sizes too!

If You Love It, Buy It

This is super true with kid’s clothes – does your little girl need a blue denim jacket AND a pink denim jacket? Probably not. But at $5 for the first and a sale color price of $2 for the second… get them both and you won’t regret it! Worst case scenario, your kiddo barely wears them, and you donate both for another kid to enjoy.

Be Patient

If you’re not finding exactly what you’re looking for, just try again in a couple weeks. You don’t have to settle… just give it a little time.

Happy Thrifting!

September Thrift Haul

September was quite the busy month, so it’s no surprise that I didn’t have very many opportunities to go thrifting. And the less opportunities = less thrift gold. That’s just the way it works. With that being said, I did find TWO fantastic items that make my heart pitter-pat.

Mahogany top, $6.99

How adorable is the pattern on this 100% cotton top? I love the v-neck, the elbow-length sleeves and the little slit on each side. I wasn’t familiar with the brand, so I googled it and found the The Mahogany Company specializes in sleepwear… so this top may be a sleepwear top. It doesn’t match the design of any of their other offerings though, so maybe it was a non-sleeping top that they previously offered? Any which way, it doesn’t really matter. I like it. It’s adorable and will totally look great with a pair of denim shorts, tucked into a skirt, or layered under a cardigan for work.

Target Pleated Running Skort, $5.99

I can’t even tell you how thrilled I was to find this adorable pleated running skort. Yeah, I know, it’s only a Target brand skirt. However, I had recently looked at an almost identical one on a recent Target trip and decided that I didn’t need to spend $25 on another running skort. However, when I came across one in my size for $6… well, that’s just a darn lucky deal. Even better, it fits great and I feel so dang cute in it!

August Thrift Haul

Once again, I’m mixing both thrift finds and consignment finds in this monthly update. I only get the opportunity to do some consignment scrounging a few times a year, so I wanted to be sure to share some of my HOLY WOW finds.

Let’s start by checking out some home goods!

MCM Bamboo bowl, $12

You all know how much I love me some mid-century modern, so this bowl was an instant YES from me. It’s a MCM bamboo fruit bowl, but I have it sitting next to my reading spot as an adorable catch-all for my reading glasses, bookmark and chapstick.

Pink Gooseberry Pyrex bowl, $8

Pink Pyrex for less than a tenner?! That’s a ‘start the car’ moment for me. This was happily added to my Pyrex collection!

Rifle Paper Co x Corkcicle travel mugs, $18 each

Sigh. It was like these were just waiting for me to find them. I looooove Corkcicle mugs (they keep your cold stuff cold and your hot stuff hot) and I also looooove Rifle Paper Co’s floral designs. So, when I saw these two ‘new with tags’ travel mugs for $18 each (retail $40 each), I immediately added them to my arm full of stuff I was juggling. And I have used one of these pretty much every single day since I bought them (and washed them) for sipping my cold ice water all day long.

Nemadji Pottery wedding vase, $16 and Southwestern Sand pottery vase, $18

Did I need these? No. Did I immediately love them and want to add them to my desk where I could stare dreamily at them while thinking about all our Arizona and Utah adventures? Yes.

Okay, now on to the clothing purchases!

Torrid dress, $15

Once again, a ‘new with tags’ item, this time it was a $60 dress from Torrid. It’s such a happy orange color and even has pretty embroidered detailing on the bust, so I figured I’d give it a try. I already wore it to my niece’s birthday and plan to get in a couple more wears before summer disappears.

Gingham Skirt, $10

I liked the tiered gingham of this skirt and the fabric is a great weight too. However, I knew immediately that I hated the runched waistline and I planned to chop it off and add in some new elastic. It was a quick and easy project and now I have a super cute gingham skirt for all my twirling needs.

Sorel sandals, $20

This was the ‘I didn’t know my closet needed these’ item, because these were ‘new with tags’ and a great deal, so I bought them on a whim. However, I had no idea how much I needed a pair of comfortable metallic sandals… because I’ve worn these probably a half-dozen times since buying them this month.

Swedish Hasbeen Huarache Debutant sandals, $6.79

YOU GUYS! These are an insane find at Goodwill and I can’t believe they are in my size and in perfect condition. Swedish Hasbeen’s are so timeless and so freaking expensive. I tracked down this particular style and it was released as part of their Spring/Summer 2016 collection and they retailed for around $300. It looks like someone bought them and just let them hang out in their closet unworn for 8 years… because they are absolutely perfect. I’m imagining how cute they will look paired with tights and skirts this fall!