Thrift List: What I’m Looking For

When it comes to thrifting, there is a certain open mindedness that needs to come into play. You never really know what you’re going to find and fall in love with, or what the Thrifting Gods will deliver that day. Sometimes it’s nothing. Other times, it’s something awesome. However, for me it helps to always have a running thrift list in the notes app on my phone.

Typically, I’ll do a round of my favorite parts of the thrift store – dresses, skirts, sweaters – and then pull out my phone and check over my list. This helps me hone in on certain sections to give them a little extra attention.

Currently on my thrift list:

  • Jack Adidas track pants in the next size
  • Jack long sleeve t-shirts in the next size
  • Jack winter boots/hiking shoes in the next size
  • Chunky knit cotton cardigan for me (green, black, brown)
  • STEM toys – K’nex, Snap Circuits, etc

Yup, Jack stuff has pretty much taken over my current thrift list. He’s 11 and growing, so I’m always on the hunt for the next size in clothing. He will barely wear winter boots/hiking shoes before growing out of them, so it makes sense to try and find a pair that are secondhand if I can. Now that he’s a kid’s shoe size 5/women’s shoe size 7, I can check a few sections to see what’s available.  Also, he’s a STEM toy fiend and I’m happy to supply him with all the random bits and pieces possible to help him create something fantastic.

As for me, my closet is looking pretty happy these days. I’ve been purging continuously, so I definitely have many less items now than I did a few years ago. However, I like 95% of the items in my closet and it all fits. There’s maybe 5% that will be donated or sold over the next few months.

I do have a couple sweaters that are on their way out, due to me wearing the crap out of them (and I’ve used the sweater shaver many, many times), so I’m on the hunt for a perfectly chunky and soft cardigan that is mostly cotton. I see a bunch of sweaters similar to what I want, but they always have wool in them, which makes me hot and itchy.

If I were to buy retail (which I will, if I don’t find exactly what I want), I want something similar to these:

L.L. Bean Women’s Heritage Soft Cotton Fisherman Sweater – $99

L.L Bean Women’s Signature Cotton Fisherman Sweater – $149

Quince 100% Organic Cotton Oversized Cable Cardigan – $69.90

I’ve been keeping an eye out for a chunky, fisherman’s type of sweater for months, including the women’s and the men’s sections. I’m looking for something similar to the above photos — which are all 100% cotton. If I can’t find something, I’ll probably add one one of these to my Christmas list.

Now, some things I’m NOT ALLOWED to thrift:

  • Handmade crochet/knit blankets – I can not save them all. Repeat so it sinks into my brain… I. Can. Not. Save. Them. All.
  • Cups/Travel Mugs/Water Bottles – unless it’s Corksicle, it’s not allowed to come home with me. We have plenty of cups, mugs and water bottles in our cabinets and I’ve even donated a bunch recently.
  • Holiday items – unless I’m head over heels in love with it, it’s going to be a NO for me. We have plenty of Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas decorations and I don’t even use all of them each year (I like to rotate). There is no reason to buy anything else for holiday décor.
  • Wooden Pallet/Canvas Frames for artwork – for a while I kept collecting canvases and pallets so that I could paint over them. However, I still have a few in my closet that I haven’t touched and I’m not allowed to add any more to the collection until they are used.

Disclaimer: This post contains ShopStyle links. This means that clicking on a link may help me earn a small commission at no cost to you.

September Thrift Haul

After last month’s giant thrift haul, this month’s feels positively tiny. However, let’s call it ‘small but mighty’… because I still found some fabulous items to add to our home.

Stoneware pitcher, $8.49

I’m not sure if this is vintage stoneware or something new and handmade, but I love it! I picked it up at our local thrift store and put it down a few times before just committing to the fact that it needs to live in my house.

This pretty little pitcher now lives on my den bookcase with some other fabulous vases and pieces of pottery that I’ve collected over the years.

Fenton Glass Hobnail mini vase, $8

While out and about at a fun vintage/consignment shop with my friend, I found this Fenton colonial green vase from the 1960’s. I don’t have any other similar vases, so I figured I’d add this one to my collection. It certainly fits in with the rest of my mid century modern pottery and ceramics that I’ve been accidentally collecting.

Frye Deborah Deco studded short boots, $50

These are the FIND of the month! I came across these Frye boots at a little consignment store that my friend and I love, and they were tucked around a corner of a bookcase totally out of sight. They’re an 8 and I typically wear an 8.5 or even a 9 in some boots, so I slipped them on and wore them around while shopping the rest of the store. They were comfortable enough, so I made the call and spent $50 on them. When I got home and did my research, I found that they are the Frye Deborah Deco short boots and they sold for $598!

Once I put on a pair of socks with them, they were a *little* tight on the top of my left foot. So, I tried a freezer hack I saw online:

And now they fit great! I can’t wait to pair them with some of my dresses and skirts this fall. I’m hoping that as I wear them time and time again, they mold more to the shape of my feet and they get even more comfortable.

August Thrift Haul

This month was my most prolific thrifting month with a total of nine items — and I found everything from clothing to housewares to vintage 1950’s casserole dishes. Part of it was because I had the time to hit three stores over the course of the month and another part was just luck. So, let’s check out this month’s finds!

ACDC sweatshirt, $2.99

Do I like ACDC? Yes! Do I like super soft and lightweight sweatshirts? Yes! Do I like purchasing a super soft ACDC sweatshirt for $2.99? YES!! This purchase was a total no-brainer. It’s really soft and comfy and doesn’t show any signs of wear. It’s the perfect casual topper for throwing over my pajamas on a chilly morning out in the sunroom with my coffee. {swoon}

Denim jacket, $8.99

I know, I know… ANOTHER denim jacket, but I have plans for this denim jacket (Crafting Your Own Signature Style: A Me Made Denim Jacket). I haven’t started the project yet, but sometime soon the sleeves are coming off and some paint/embroidery is going on. I’ll keep you posted. And even if it turns out terrible, it was a $9 investment for some crafty fun.

Converse shoes, $14.79

I love a classic white pair of low top converse shoes and I’ve been looking for a pair in super great condition for a while. These happen to be the “Chuck 70 Vintage Canvas low tops” and they are currently being sold on the Converse website for $85. They had a small spot on the canvas, which was easily scrubbed off and they are currently in the middle of a make-over with some embroidery thread!

Starbucks Reusable Hot Cups (set of 6), $5.99

These were all the rage a few years ago with people buying them up as soon as they hit the shelves and then reselling them for 5x the price. Guess the market burst on them, because there were like 5 sets at the thrift store for $5.99. Jack loves color changing cups, so I picked up a set for him to use as his nighttime water cups. Unfortunately, they don’t actually change color for hot or cold water. Bummer. They’re still good cups though, so they are getting used.

Cronin pottery tulip casserole dish and lid, $5.49 on sale for $4

I love this fabulous little casserole dish and lid from the 1950’s and I have the matching pitcher in my China cabinet. I bought this for $4 and similar dishes are being sold online for $30 – 55. I plan to use this one though and it may eventually find it’s way to my China cabinet with its other mid-century pottery friends. (Featured in previous post: Google Lens: The Easiest Way to Track Down Thrift Finds!)

Rainbow sleeveless top, $8.99

Not a fancy brand, but a super cute pattern. I though that this shirt would look nice with some of my skirts, so I’m planning to wear this before the summer weather turns into fall.

Soma top, $2.99

I pretty much sleep exclusively in Soma pajamas, so I’m super excited to find this comfy Soma top at the thrift store. It will be a great pajama topper for when it’s chilly! And honestly, I’d wear this with non-pajamas too because it’s really soft and cute.

Talbots blouse, $6.99

Yet another lesson in “don’t trust the size tags” at a thrift store. This pretty cotton eyelet shirt from Talbots is marked as a 1X and totally fits like a large. It’s also navy blue (not black), which I don’t have much of in my closet. I’ve already worn it to work:

J.Jill new with tags skirt, $9.99

I wasn’t sure if this one was a keeper when I bought it, since I didn’t try it on. However, it was new-with-tags so I figured I’d give it a shot. It’s a pretty dark blue and very, very lightweight – like parachute material. I wore it over the weekend though and it is NOT a winner. The fabric gets super clingy and full of static while driving, so every time I get out of the car I’m yanking it down and away from my body. As soon as I finished my Sunday errands, I ripped it off my body and stuck it in my sale/re-donate pile. Well, they can’t all be winners!