My December Stitch Fix: Another Buy-it-All Box?

Bring on the eggnog and Christmas cookies, because it’s time for my December Stitch Fix!

I’ve basically been looking forward to this Fix since about two minutes after I sent my November Fix back… so as soon as the box arrived I went from clothed to nekkid in about 19 seconds so I could try everything on.

Don’t worry, the postlady was gone so I didn’t scare the bejesus out of her.

I was extra excited to get this Fix before Christmas so I have a couple new things to wear for our various holiday events – I have some girlfriends coming over for a Bellinis, Brunch & Love Actually party, two family Christmas dinners AND two planned dates with my handsome hubby! Also, I listened to all your feedback about wanting larger pictures with MORE outfit options… so I hope you like the THIRTEEN pictures in this post!

{For my new friends, if you’re wondering what a Stitch Fix is, please check out this post. If you want to know why I spend money to have a stylist send me clothes and whether I’m getting rich off these reviews, click on this one. If you’re wondering if I ever regret a Stitch Fix purchase, give a clickty click over here. If you’re feeling super stalkery and want to see ALL my Stitch Fix posts, you get on with your bad self and click around here. Okay, all caught up? Let’s join the rest of the class now…}

In the notes section for my December Fix, here is what I wrote: “Stylist Sara J again. It’s getting COLD so I’d love to see sweaters – I tend to like v-necks and cardigans the best. Chunky & Warm, but not scratchy! I REALLY want to try the Kirsten Sequin Raglan Tee by Pixley (please, please!!) because it would be great for xmas! Also I’d love to try the Loveappella Evie Draw String Funnel Neck Sweatshirt & the Tobie Folklore Scarf Dress.”

I thought by being much more specific with my requests – including some items I’d love to see – I’d be more likely to get a Fix I loved. I was initially a little bummed out when I opened my box and read Sara’s note that they didn’t have any of my requests in stock. However, I totally forgive her because she really delivered and this Fix ROCKED!!

Let’s see what I got!

Item #1: Market and Spruce Alan French Terry Asymmetrical Zip Cardigan – $68
My initial thoughts when I saw this cardigan is that it looks super similar to one I just ordered and returned to another company. That one fit super weird and was kind of scratchy, but this one is just the opposite. It’s super soft, lightweight but still substantial, and makes me want to throw it on with everything from a pair of black jeans to yoga pants. I actually like this cardigan open a lot more than I like it closed, but I showed you how it looks each way in case you are interested in requesting it for yourself. The sleeves are a bit long, but I actually love an extra-long sleeve in the wintertime.

I styled it for you three different ways. First, I threw it on like I’d normally wear it on the weekends, with a t-shirt, distressed jeans and my fabulous Fryes:

Stitch Fix Review - Market and Spruce Alan French Terry Asymmetrical Cardigan 2 - Pocketful of Joules

Then, I gave you a little more of a dressed up look with a colorful tank top, black skinny jeans and knee-high boots:

Stitch Fix Review - Market and Spruce Alan French Terry Asymmetrical Cardigan - Pocketful of Joules

For the last styling, I zipped it up over a cute striped tank top and a pair of yoga pants, since this is how I will probably end up wearing it on my work-from-home days:

Stitch Fix Review - Market and Spruce Alan French Terry Asymmetrical Cardigan 3 - Pocketful of Joules

Item #2: Pink Martini Moises Floral Printed Colorblock Dress – $78
When I first saw this dress in my box I was kind of in love with the adorable fox printed fabric. I love a nice and subtle animal print, don’t you? The top of the dress is a super soft cotton mix and the bottom has a more substantial fabric. At first, I was a bit concerned that the high-waisted fit looked a bit young on me. However, when I styled it for cooler weather with fleece-lined tights, knee boots and a green cardigan it looks pretty darn cute.

Here it is as if it weren’t actually 3o degrees on my front porch:

Stitch Fix Review - Pink Martini Moises Floral Printed Colorblock Dress 2- Pocketful of Joules

Here is how I’d wear it now to keep warm:

Stitch Fix Review - Pink Martini Moises Floral Printed Colorblock Dress - Pocketful of Joules

Item #3: Desires Nero Hooded Long-Sleeve Sweater – $68
Okay a sweater is right up my alley and totally what I was wanting in this Fix! The weather is getting quite frightful in Maryland and I was hoping for something that would keep me warm while still being cute. Sara obviously took my notes asking for something chunky and warm seriously when she choose this sweater for me. Also, the neckline is really similar to the drawstring funnel neck sweatshirt that I asked for… so YAY Sara!

Here’s a close up of the neckline:

Stitch Fix Review - Desires Nero Hooded Sweater - close up - Pocketful of Joules

I styled it with a pair of gray skinny jeans and knee boots for a typical running around (but still staying warm and looking cute) look:

Stitch Fix Review - Desires Nero Hooded Sweater - Pocketful of Joules

And here it is dressed down even more with a pair of jeans and chucks:

Stitch Fix Review - Desires Nero Hooded Sweater 2 - Pocketful of Joules

Item #4: Skies are Blue Gabrielle Embroidered Bib Knit Top – $48
Hmm… does this shirt remind you of anything? Take a little gander over to the right and check out my profile picture. It’s like shirt twinsies, right?! However, my summer embroidered top is black, super flowy and short-sleeved. This one is navy blue, fits perfectly and has nice extra-long sleeves that will keep me warm this winter (and fall and spring). Oh, and it’s a super soft cotton. I love this top and already wore it for my girlie get together over the weekend. So this one is obviously a keeper!

First up is my comfortable, yet sassy look with distressed jeans and my Fryes:

Stitch Fix Review - Skies are Blue Gabrielle Embroidered Bib Knit Top 3 - Pocketful of Joules

Then, I dressed it up a little — which would be perfect for Christmas dinner — by styling the top with my gray skinny jeans and knee boots:

Stitch Fix Review - Skies are Blue Gabrielle Embroidered Bib Knit Top 2 - Pocketful of Joules

For the last look, I added on a comfy boyfriend sweater for those extra cold days:

Stitch Fix Review - Skies are Blue Gabrielle Embroidered Bib Knit Top - Pocketful of Joules

Item #5: Collective Concepts Illiana Embellished Trim Tab-Sleeve Blouse – $68
I really wanted a little sparkle this holiday season and this top has just a smidge of sparkle along the front. It is navy blue and a little bit transparent, so I’d have to wear a tank top with this one. However, I think it can dress up a pair of destroyed jeans AND look equally cute styled for a typical workday. This could be one of those sleeper pieces in my wardrobe – it looks pretty simple now, but could certainly be worn with pretty much everything!

Here’s the top styled for a date night with my handsome husband — I added in my sassy distressed jeans and some leopard print heels. Roar, baby.

Stitch Fix Review - Collective Concepts Illiana Embellished Bouse - Pocketful of Joules

And here is how I would style it for work:

Stitch Fix Review - Collective Concepts Illiana Embellished Bouse 2 - Pocketful of Joules

Help me!
Now it’s time for you to help me decide what I should buy! I purposefully didn’t give you too much information on which ways I was leaning because I LOVE getting your feedback. Is this one of those buy-it-all boxes? If I do decide to purchase the whole Fix I will save $77.50 with the buy 5 discount (in addition to my $20 styling fee credit)… making my total for all 5 pieces $232.50.

I’d love to hear your feedback, so please leave me some comments below and tell me what you think!

1/13/15 Update: I got bogged down in holidays (and holiday cookies) and totally forgot to tell you which items I decided to purchase! I bought the Market and Spruce Alan French Terry Asymmetrical Zip Cardigan and the Skies are Blue Gabrielle Embroidered Bib Knit Top. In the few weeks since I bought them, I’ve worn them both a ton so I’m totally happy with my choices. Thank you to everyone for your feedback!

Disclaimer: This post is not sponsored by Stitch Fix, I pay for the $20 styling fee and any clothing I purchase with my own hard-earned money. If you enjoyed my review and decide to try Stitch Fix for yourself, the biggest compliment you can give me is by using my referral link. Thank you to anyone who chooses to click through and support my shopping addiction!

Psssst…Do you love checking out what other people received in their Fixes? I added quick links to every single one of my reviews on my Stitch Fix Reviews page!

My November Stitch Fix: A Total Turkey?

It seems like it’s been a super long time since my last Fix in October, doesn’t it? I guess this past month has been so busy that it just FEELS like a lot of time has passed, but it’s really only been a month + a week.

I was actually thinking of skipping my November Fix because I’ve been working through my existing closet with #thejoulespurge and I’ve also done a bit of season-change-induced shopping. However, I LOVE being surprised with the clothes that Stitch Fix sends me so I decided to get a delivery right before Thanksgiving.

Maybe my hopes were too high though, because when I opened the box I was super disappointed…

{For my new friends, if you’re wondering what a Stitch Fix is, please check out this post. If you want to know why I spend money to have a stylist send me clothes and whether I’m getting rich off these reviews, click on this one. If you’re wondering if I ever regret a Stitch Fix purchase, give a clickty click over here. If you’re feeling super stalkery and want to see ALL my Stitch Fix posts, you get on with your bad self and click around here. Okay, all caught up? Let’s join the rest of the class now…}

In the notes section for this month’s Fix, here is what I put: “Stylist: Sara J again. It’s getting colder in Maryland so let’s do some layering stuff – sweaters, ¾ or full sleeve tops, a fun blazer, skinny jeans… I’m open to it all, I just hate to be cold! Also, check out my pinterest page because I updated it for fall!”

So, did I get anything to keep me warm? Is EVERYTHING going back? Let’s check it out together.

Actually, before we check it out I have to warn you that I kind of look like death warmed over in these pictures. I’ve been struck down with some kind of daycare plague and haven’t slept for the past three nights due to coughing ALL NIGHT LONG. I’ve tried cough medicines and nothing is working. At this point, I’ve coughed so hard that I burst a blood vessel in my eye and have actually made myself sick a couple of times. In short, it sucks. So if I look rough… that’s why.

On to the fashion show!

Collective Concepts Melandry Chevron Blouse - Pocketful of Joules

Collective Concepts close up - Pocketful of Joules

Item #1: Collective Concepts Melandry Dotted Chevron Print Blouse — $68
In the fall and winter, I tend to do a lot of layering so that I can deal with the freezing cold outside and the fluctuating temperatures at my various office locations. This type of shirt is perfect, because I can pair it with a blazer or cardigan for an extra layer of warmth. I can also throw on a tank top underneath it all to keep me extra toasty.

When I opened the box I liked the pattern with its fun mix of blues and greens. I feel like this pattern could go either way though and you may think it’s the ugliest thing you’ve ever seen. When I put it on though, I realized the fit was off on me. Instead of draping nicely, the buttons strained across my chest. So sad, otherwise I would have snapped this top up in a heartbeat! For my picture, I styled it with a pair of black skinny pants (Democracy, by way of Nordstrom Rack) and my leopard print heels (Target).

Keep or Return? It doesn’t fit, so it’s going back.

Peppercorn Hazel Metallic Striped Knit Top - Pocketful of Joules

Peppercorn sweater close up - Pocketful of Joules

Item #2: Peppercorn Hazel Metallic Striped Knit Top — $48
When I opened this month’s Fix I was super excited to see a bit of metallic thread. With Christmas coming up, I like to add a little sparkle to my wardrobe. However, this sweater is pretty terrible in person – the fabric is SUPER itchy and it just fits like a big old uninteresting box. If it had a deep v-neck, it might have looked a bit more flattering… but as it is, I pretty much hate it. Even with my super cute red pants (a previous Stitch Fix) and my knee-high boots (Naturalizer).

Keep or Return? I hate it, so it’s going back.

Kut from the Kloth Moto Jacket - Pocketful of Joules

Close up moto jacket - Pocketful of Joules

Item #3: Kut From The Kloth Cia Boucle Sleeve Terry Moto Jacket — $98
First off, I’m kind of in love with anything from Kut from the Kloth. I never even tried this brand until Stitch Fix started sending it to me and now I search it out in stores (especially Nordstrom Rack where I’ve found some awesome deals). So, a big THANK YOU to Stitch Fix for introducing us! My initial thought when I saw this jacket was coming to me was, “ANOTHER moto jacket?!” I already got one in a previous Fix that I wear pretty regularly.

I decided to keep an open mind though, until I opened the box. BLEGH. So UGLY! I can’t even believe this is by the same brand that I’ve fallen in love with! The mix of fabrics is like a super cheap sweatshirt made dorky, awkward love with a grandma sweater. What. The. Heck. I tried it on anyway though, with my favorite jeans (Kut from the Kloth) and a pair of sparkly Toms. And um… well, does my face spell it out for you?

Yuck face

This is absolutely NOT living in my house, especially for $98?! I hated it so much that I immediately went into my Stitch Fix account and made a note that said, “no more moto jackets… I have plenty!”

Keep or Return? Nope. Not going to happen. Ever.

41Hawthorn Benson Blazer - Pocketful of Joules

Blazer close up - Pocketful of Joules

Item #4: 41Hawthorn Benson 3/4 Ruched Sleeve Blazer — $78
I specifically asked for a blazer in this month’s Fix because I have a lot of work events coming up which require me to be more dressed up. I have three in heavy rotation, a black one, a grey one and a green velvet one… so I wanted something different. I pinned a bunch of cute patterned blazers to my pinterest board, hoping that I’d get something similar. But instead, I got this. It is a navy blue sweatshirt material fitted blazer with stripes on the inside. I tried it on with a striped top from Anthropologie, my black work-horse pants (Democracy) and my leopard print wedges.

Sigh. It’s the SAME blazer I’ve seen on pretty much everyone for like a year now. Also, since it’s made out a super casual cotton there is no way I could wear it to work for an event. I was thinking about using it for a sweater replacement for work, but for being made out of such a comfy material this is really NOT very comfortable to wear. It has some pretty substantial shoulder pads, and the upper arms and back sections are both quite tight.

Keep or Return? GOING BACK.

Kut from the Kloth Jonathan Skinny Cords - Pocketful of Joules

cords close up - Pocketful of Joules

Item #5: Kut From The Kloth Jonathan Corduroy Skinny Pant — $68
Okay, here we go. I know for a fact that Kut From the Kloth pants are my friends because I have a pair of their skinny jeans and a pair of their bootcut jeans. As you can imagine, after trying on all the rest of the losers in my box, I was crossing my fingers that these fit properly!

I don’t have any other skinny cords in my wardrobe and actually pinned a couple pairs on my Pinterest page with the thought that winter is coming and I could use a pair. I feel like these can be a really versatile piece for upcoming holiday events, normal weekend fun and even a more casual workday.

YAY, they fit! They are comfortable! The blue is pretty! We finally have a keeper. Which is great, because I really didn’t want to lose my $20 styling fee! Here’s a closer look at the shade of blue:

pants in light

I styled them with a Daniel Rainn tank top from a previous fix, a pink cardigan (Marshalls) and my knee high boots (Naturalizer).

Keep or Return? Looks like they are my only keeper from this Fix!

Normally now is where I would ask you to help me decide what to buy… but the decision is pretty darn clear. To be honest, I was super disappointed in this Fix (hence the Turkey title). I had really hoped for an interesting blazer and a great sweater or two for the upcoming cold season. But that’s what you get with a service like this – sometimes you love them and sometimes you hate them.

I would love your feedback on my pictures from this month’s Fix though. This month I made them much bigger (instead of the collages I normally do) and included some close ups so you could see the details from each piece. Do you like this way better, or do you prefer I return to the old way of having a collage of a couple different outfits made from each item?

Disclaimer: This post is not sponsored by Stitch Fix, I pay for the $20 styling fee and any clothing I purchase with my own hard-earned money. If you enjoyed my review and decide to try Stitch Fix for yourself, the biggest compliment you can give me is by using my referral link. Thank you to anyone who chooses to click through and support my shopping addiction!

Psssst…Do you love checking out what other people received in their Fixes? I added quick links to every single one of my reviews on my Stitch Fix Reviews page!

My October Stitch Fix: FALLing in Love Again

It’s STITCH FIX TIME!

Am I a little excited?
YES I AM!

Am I making super corny pun’s in the post title?
Heck YEAH!

That’s right… there’s shouting. And arms waving. And even a bit of booty shaking. Because I LOVE doing these posts and hearing back from you guys!

{For my new friends, if you’re wondering what a Stitch Fix is, please check out this post. If you want to know why I spend money to have a stylist send me clothes and whether I’m getting rich off these reviews, click on this one. If you’re wondering if I ever regret a Stitch Fix purchase, give a clickty click over here. If you’re feeling super stalkery and want to see ALL my Stitch Fix posts, you get on with your bad self and click around here. Okay, all caught up? Let’s join the rest of the class now…}

In the notes section for this month’s Fix, here is what I put: “Stylist: Sara J again. This month’s Fix will come right before my anniversary weekend at a B&B with my husband. I’d love something sassy to wear to go to dinner and walk around Baltimore. Fall transition options would be great and please no more sleeveless tops for now. Check out my pinterest page!”

So, did I end up with anything to wear for our upcoming weekend?

October Stitch Fix Review - Pocketful of Joules

Check out the FASHION SHOW and YOU be the judge!

Olive and Oak Mulliken Raglan Striped Knit Shirt - Stitch Fix

Item #1: Olive & Oak Mulliken Raglan Striped Knit Shirt – $48
I have been dying for an awesome mixed-stripe shirt! Remember how sad I was when I had to send the sweater from last month’s Fix back?!  I’ve had a couple striped tops on my Pinterest board FOREVER and recently pinned this exact shirt, so I was super excited to get it in my Fix.

This shirt is SO incredibly soft – putting it on is like slipping into a well-worn pajama top. The colors are so pretty and there is even a band of burgundy around the neckline. I styled it for two kinds of date’s with my hubby. The first would be a normal dinner out with Jack – my distressed jeans (Stitch Fix) and my green chucks make this outfit cute, but also appropriate for toddler wrangling. The second look is something that I could wear this weekend – pretty sparkly necklace (J.Crew) my grey skinny jeans (Kate Spade) and a pair of leopard print heels (Target).

My only issue with striped tops (and this could totally be a me being crazy thing) is that when you have a larger chest it kind of drives me crazy keeping the stripes straight across so that they don’t get all wonky and look weird. Also, um… do the stripes make me look kinda chubby? I haven’t been doing so well with my diet and I’m up a couple pounds… which all seem to have found my tummy.

Keep or Return? I’m leaning towards buying it. What do you think?

Gilli Kary Drape Front Knit Dress - Stitch Fix

Item #2: Gilli Kary Drape Front Knit Dress – $64
I HAVE been on quite a dress kick lately and love one that is comfortable, but work appropriate. When I first saw this one, I thought the cobalt blue color was beautiful and would transition well to winter with some black tights and a sweater.

My stylist recommended I wear it with my quilted faux leather jacket from my last Fix and I really like that she thought about what was already in my closet when sending it. For each picture I’m wearing a statement necklace (J.Crew) and sassy leopard heels (Target). Unfortunately I’m not a fan of knit dresses, because they cling in all the wrong places. You can’t tell in the pictures, but I’m totally sucking my stomach in so hard that I was in danger of passing out. Also, if I turn to the side, the high waist makes me look like I could be wearing a maternity dress.

I styled this one for a date night, with and without the jacket. I have to admit, it does look pretty cute in the pictures and I could probably make it work with some hardcore spanx underneath.

Keep or Return? As much as I love the color, I’m going to have to pass on this one. While it’s okay to break out the confining undergarments on an as-needed basis, the last thing I want on our anniversary weekend is to feel totally uncomfortable the entire time.

Mystree Maiya Canvas Jacket - Stitch Fix

Item #3: Mystree Maiya Canvas Jacket – $88
Now this jacket is something I would never even pick up in a store to try on, but the mix of materials is really cool and interesting. My stylist recommended that I try the jacket with the two tops she sent, so that is exactly what I did. For the first two looks, I’m wearing my distressed jeans (Stitch Fix) and a pair of grey boots (9 West). For the third look, I’m wearing a pair of Kut from the Kloth bootcut jeans that I recently picked up at Nordstrom Rack. I never even heard of that brand before I started getting Fixes and now I’m in love with their jeans!

This jacket feels like a super comfortable sweater when it’s on and I was super tempted to add it to my coat collection. However, it is too similar to the Mystree Skylar Asymmetrical Jacket I received in July. Even though fall is my absolute favorite and I’m a sucker for a cute jacket, winter is coming soon and I don’t really need another lightweight option.

Keep or return? I really like this jacket, but it’s too similar to one I already own.

41Hawthorn Mission Abstract Dot Print blouse - Stitch Fix

Item #4: 41Hawthorn Mission Abstract Dot Print Blouse – $68
Speaking of loving fall, this shirt is like fall exploded all over it… in a good way! I love the rust and orange colors – it reminds me of a tree changing color. The fit is okay, maybe a little tight in the bust if I move around in weird positions. The neckline is pretty though, kind of like a curved v-neck. For the first styling, I’m wearing a date night outfit of skinny jeans (Kut from the Kloth) and wedges (Toms). For the second look, I’m all set for the office in a navy pencil skirt (Banana Republic), canvas blazer (Anthropologie) and heels (DSW). My only question is… is it TOO fall? I’m on the fence with this one.

Keep or return? I really like the colors of this top, but I’m not 100% loving the fit on me. I’m looking to you guys to tell me what you think!

Sweet Rain Toma Floral Print Blouse - Stitch Fix

Item #5: Toma Floral Print Short-Sleeve Blouse – $44
Oh my gosh, I’m in LOVE with this shirt. It is that magical mixture of floral and fall/winter appropriate. Its short sleeved, but would look fantastic under a cardigan or blazer too. The fit is great and there is no pulling at all on the chest area or arms. There is even a cute little tab-sleeve detail that I love (you can see it on the close up picture at the top of this post).

I love this shirt so much that I styled it three different ways. First, if the weather is nice I would absolutely wear this walking around Baltimore for our anniversary weekend – bootcut jeans (Kut from the Kloth) and that pair of leopard heels (Target) that keeps showing up. I’ll probably bring flatter shoes if we will be doing a lot of walking through. For the other two looks, I could wear either of these to the office. The middle look has a long necklace (Wantable) and a cranberry colored pencil skirt (Banana Republic). The last look has my swing skirt from a previous Fix (Stitch Fix), the same necklace and a colorful belt (Banana Republic).

Keep or return? I’m pretty much making googly eyes at this shirt, so I’m going to have to buy it!

Help me!
Now it’s time for you to chime in and tell me what I should buy! I’m leaning towards buying the striped shirt and the floral shirt. I’m undecided about the fall blouse and I’m passing on the jacket and the dress. I’d love to hear your feedback, so please leave me some comments below and tell me what you think!

Also, I’d like to give a big THANK YOU to the person who used my referral code a couple days ago. Because you were so nice as to use my code when signing up for your own Stitch Fix, I received $25 in my account. So anything I purchase will be $25 less. Thank you!

10/16/14 Update: Thank you ALL for your feedback! I appreciate each and every comment that you guys take the time to leave! After much deliberation I decided to JUST buy what I love… so I bought the floral top. The fit was perfect, I can imagine it with lots of different outfits and {best of all} I’m already planning when I can wear it! Stay tuned for my next Fix… I have it scheduled to arrive Thanksgiving week!

Disclaimer: This post is not sponsored by Stitch Fix, I pay for the $20 styling fee and any clothing I purchase with my own hard-earned money. If you enjoyed my review and decide to try Stitch Fix for yourself, the biggest compliment you can give me is by using my referral link. Thank you to anyone who chooses to click through and support my shopping addiction!

Psssst…Do you love checking out what other people received in their Fixes? I added quick links to every single one of my reviews on my Stitch Fix Reviews page!